| Platinum | Crumbl Cookies Tyler |
| Gold | Village Bakery |
| Silver | Sister2Sister Cookies |
| Bronze | Smallcakes |
| Top Pick | Cinnaholic |
| Top Pick | Dang Good Cookie Co |
| Top Pick | Get Baked By Christina |
| Top Pick | Great American Cookies |
| Top Pick | Janie's Cakes |
| Top Pick | Sister 2 Sister Cookies |