| Platinum | Lemon Yellow Latin Bites |
| Gold | Papacita's of Tyler |
| Silver | Chuy's |
| Bronze | Don Juan Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Javi's |
| Top Pick | Posados Cafe |
| Top Pick | Taqueria El Lugar |
| Top Pick | The Jalapeno Tree Mexican Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Villa Montez |
| Top Pick | Villaggio del Vino |